[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: Oddball Question



PureBytes Links

Trading Reference Links

Hello Dion,

DK> Does each entry in this file represent a single bar of data? I see
DK> that  some  days end at 3:00 PM while most days have an additional
DK> bar of data, 3:15 PM.

actually all days have a 3:15 close price.  i include this because
everyone was asking what the sp closed at.  it is not used in the
calculations, the 3:15 price that is.

DK> Since  Oddball  is  based on the 7 bar ROC it seems that the extra
DK> (eighth) bar would throw off the results.

actually you can use it if you wish, i have in the past.  not saying
it's better or worst.

DK> Am  I  right  to  assume  that  a testing dataset should contain 7
DK> hourly bars per day, 9:00 AM through 3:00 PM?

correct - that was done because i have found that dependability means
as much as anything when it comes to profitability.  that's why i do
not use entry stops or mm stops.

also  i  would like to state that the missing data issues were know by
me  as  far  back a 1992. back then the ned davis platform i ran ob on
created  a  synthetic  data  price  to  fill any missing data. it just
assumed  that  using  the  last  most  recent data as a proxy was good
enough.  so  if  you had a last price on a holiday at 12 noon it would
carry that price on to the 3 o'clock close.

years  latter  when  ts came along i re created this in ts using a dll
and  some  other  fancy  stuff to create a real time perpetual futures
contract also. after much testing and thinking i decided to use what i
had  and  make  due with it. my thinking was about dependability again
and  any  idiot  could  just  let  the thing run as is. i actually had
better  results allowing this seemingly random event to take place, so
i  decided  to  leave it. i have been happy with things that way there
are  but  i  am  certain  as  i  have  maintained  there  is  room for
improvement.

i  certainly  know  there  are  better  way  to  do some things but my
intentions  were  to  give  away something robust that could withstand
much punishment.  i am very appreciative to all those who have opened
the flood gates of giving and working together, thank you all!

DK> Thanks much!

-- 
Best regards,
 Mark