[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: MAJOR FLAW in SYSTEM TESTER



PureBytes Links

Trading Reference Links


Take a look at AmiBroker.  Does everything MS 
does, and permits testing with multiple stocks, as well as use of script in 
coding.  All for the outrageous price of $60.
<BLOCKQUOTE 
style="PADDING-RIGHT: 0px; PADDING-LEFT: 5px; MARGIN-LEFT: 5px; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 2px solid; MARGIN-RIGHT: 0px">
  ----- Original Message ----- 
  <DIV 
  style="BACKGROUND: #e4e4e4; FONT: 10pt arial; font-color: black">From: 
  <A title=Michel.Amelinckx@xxxxxxxxxx 
  href="mailto:Michel.Amelinckx@xxxxxxxxxx";>Michel Amelinckx 
  To: <A title=metastock@xxxxxxxxxxxxx 
  href="mailto:metastock@xxxxxxxxxxxxx";>metastock@xxxxxxxxxxxxx 
  Sent: Sunday, July 01, 2001 11:08 
AM
  Subject: RE: MAJOR FLAW in SYSTEM 
  TESTER
  Yes I believe for beginning investors or traders MS is a great 
  product,also to do Technical analysis by hand MS is great (if you don't 
  botherthe crashes now an then by moving some object).  But ones you 
  want to dosome real advanced system testing then you are left with one 
  hand onyour back.M.-----Original Message-----From: <A 
  href="mailto:owner-metastock@xxxxxxxxxxxxx";>owner-metastock@xxxxxxxxxxxxx[mailto:owner-metastock@xxxxxxxxxxxxx] 
  On Behalf Of Dan HarelsSent: zondag 1 juli 2001 08:02To: <A 
  href="mailto:metastock@xxxxxxxxxxxxx";>metastock@xxxxxxxxxxxxxSubject: 
  Re: MAJOR FLAW in SYSTEM TESTERTwo things:1.  
  Business is Business2.  Money talks, BS walksAs the 4th of 
  July approaches, I want to highlight two points that havemade the USA 
  the only Superpower.  The third and fourth points are the 2nd 
  Amendment and capital punishment.  I won't go into those here.  
  Ibelieve Metastock offers good value.Dan>From: 
  "wavemechanic" <<A 
  href="mailto:wd78@xxxxxxxxxxxx";>wd78@xxxxxxxxxxxx>>Reply-To: <A 
  href="mailto:metastock@xxxxxxxxxxxxx";>metastock@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>To: 
  <<A 
  href="mailto:metastock@xxxxxxxxxxxxx";>metastock@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>>Subject: 
  Re: MAJOR FLAW in SYSTEM TESTER>Date: Sat, 30 Jun 2001 08:21:13 
  -0400>>MessageWhat is really neat about the Equis approach to 
  bugs is thatthey >fix the bug in the next version and then charge 
  you to upgrade.   A >perpetual motion 
  machine.>   ----- Original Message ----->   
  From: Michel Amelinckx>   To: <A 
  href="mailto:metastock@xxxxxxxxxxxxx";>metastock@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>   
  Sent: Saturday, June 30, 2001 5:26 AM>   Subject: RE: MAJOR 
  FLAW in SYSTEM TESTER>>>   At least one person 
  who is not a fraet to tell the truth. In fact >Equis>is spending 
  much more time in publishing their own so calledPerformance 
  >Systems and their Data on demand than they are fixing the TONS of 
  bugor >flaws.>   
  M.>     -----Original 
  Message----->     From: <A 
  href="mailto:owner-metastock@xxxxxxxxxxxxx";>owner-metastock@xxxxxxxxxxxxx 
  >[mailto:owner-metastock@xxxxxxxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of Lionel 
  Issen>     Sent: zaterdag 30 juni 2001 
  01:40>     To: <A 
  href="mailto:metastock@xxxxxxxxxxxxx";>metastock@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>     
  Subject: Re: MAJOR FLAW in SYSTEM 
  TESTER>>>     There are several flaws 
  in the system tester.This has been >discussed>here, but Equis 
  wont/can't correct the problems.>     Lionel 
  Issen>     <A 
  href="mailto:lissen@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx";>lissen@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>       
  ----- Original Message ----->       From: 
  neo>       To: <A 
  href="mailto:metastock@xxxxxxxxxxxxx";>metastock@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>       
  Sent: Friday, June 29, 2001 1:14 
  PM>       Subject: MAJOR FLAW in SYSTEM 
  TESTER>>>       I called 
  MetaStock support today because I was curious about >some>odd 
  results with the System Tester (ST). I then tested it myself toverify 
  >it. THERE  IS A MAJOR FLAW IN THE SYSTEM 
  TESTER.>>       If one places a 
  close long and a close short position and both >the>close and 
  the entry in the opposite direction are hit on that day, the >position 
  will be closed but THE OPPOSITE POSITION WILL NOT BE ENTERED.It >is 
  even worse if you choose to close on open the following day. The 
  >opposite signal will not be allowed to trigger until the following 
  day.>>       To test this I used 
  the following simple system:>       Enter 
  Long: Cross(Mov(C ,3 ,S ), Mov(C ,18 ,S ) 
  )>       Close Long: Cross(Mov(C ,18 ,S 
  ), Mov(C ,3 ,S ) )>       Enter Short: 
  Cross(Mov(C ,18 ,S ), Mov(C ,3 ,S ) 
  )>       Close Short: Cross(Mov(C ,3 ,S 
  ), Mov(C ,18 ,S ) )>>       
  Because the Enter Long & Close Short as well as the Enter Short 
  >&>Close Long are identical, one would expect to show at 
  every point botha >closing of one position and an opening of the 
  other. This does 
  nothappen!>>       The same is 
  true for Experts. If both a Close and an Enter are>triggered on the 
  same day, only 1 symbol will be displayed. They are >displayed in order 
  from top down.>>       I suggest 
  two actions. First, copy the message above and send 
  it>to>MetaStock Feedback 
  at:>>       <A 
  href="mailto:suggestions@xxxxxxxxx";>suggestions@xxxxxxxxx>>       
  Second, until this is fixed, test only longs or shorts by 
  >themselves>unless you are using a reversal system where you are 
  not using Close.>>       Below is 
  information from the MetaStock Help 
  file.>>       
  neo>       
  ________________________________>>       
  This is the page in MetaStock help 
  file:>>       The System Editor 
  Dialog>>       The System Editor 
  dialog lets you name the system test, store >notes>regarding the 
  system, and define the four trading 
  rules.>       The trading rules use the 
  formula syntax explained in theMetaStock >formula language section 
  (see What is the MetaStock Formula Language?).>This syntax is very 
  similar to the syntax used to enter formulas in >spreadsheets.  
  Each trading rule may contain up to 1024 characters.If >you are 
  unfamiliar with the MetaStock formula language, you should see>What 
  is the MetaStock Formula 
  Language?.>>       Remember that a 
  trading system can be in one of three different>states:  long, 
  short, or out.>>       When out, 
  simple interest is earned at the rate specified in the>System Testing 
  Options dialog (see System Testing 
  Options).>       You use the four tabs to 
  select which rule to display and 
  edit.>>       Enter Long.  
  This rule specifies when the system should buy >long.  
  A>long position can only be entered when the system is short or 
  out.When in >a long position, this rule is 
  ignored.>>       Close Long.  
  This rule specifies when the system should close a 
  >long>position.  When in a short or out position, this rule 
  is ignored.>>       Enter 
  Short.  This rule specifies when the system should sell 
  >short.>  A short position can only be entered when the 
  system is long or out.>When in a short position, this rule is 
  ignored.>>       Close 
  Short.  This rule specifies when the system should cover>(i.e., 
  close) a short position.  When in a long or out position, thisrule 
  >is 
  ignored._________________________________________________________________Get 
  your FREE download of MSN Explorer at <A 
  href="http://explorer.msn.com";>http://explorer.msn.com